History Corner: Indian Enough, Essays by Paul Chaat Smith

   Disclosure / Disclaimer: I received this ebook, free of charge, from University of Minnesota Press, via #netgalley, for review purposes on this blog. No other compensation, monetary or in kind, has been received or implied for this post. Nor was I told how to post about it. All opinions are my own


An acerbic, candid reckoning with Indigenous identity, visibility, and the messy realities of cultural change

indian enough cover

Synopsis:

In Indian Enough, curator and critic Paul Chaat Smith probes the paradox of contemporary Indigeneity: enormous, hard-won cultural visibility in museum exhibits, land acknowledgments, mascot removals, and more alongside persistent erasure in everyday life. Rejecting the easy comforts of identity politics (he was, he admits, a fan of the Land O’Lakes Butter Maiden), Smith brings “honest confusion” to his inquiry, using sharp wit and wry humor to confront the gap between symbolism and lived reality.

Both memoir and cultural critique, Indian Enough follows Smith from a suburban childhood in Washington, D.C., filled with Kurt Vonnegut and Vine Deloria Jr., through teenage years steeped in Native politics leading to a thrilling and eventually disillusioning stint with the American Indian Movement, to his pivotal role in creating the inaugural exhibitions at the National Museum of the American Indian. His insider account of NMAI exposes how well-meaning efforts to redress Native erasure can simply swap one set of stereotypes for another, and his candor shows how institutions and activists—himself included—all grapple with the tension between good intentions and political realities.

Irreverent and searching, Indian Enough tackles culture writ large—the rise of punk and the fall of AIM, pop culture as a battleground, Indigenous slaveowners and other histories we’d rather forget, MAGA Indians, and what it means to win when the ground keeps shifting. Together these essays reveal a truth that’s hard to reconcile in an era of “progress”: representation is everywhere, certainty is not.

Note: Retail e-book files for this title are screen-reader friendly with images accompanied by short alt text and/or extended descriptions.


Review: 

It would be easy to offer you 'pat' books on Native Americans for Native American month, but you know that isn't this blog. What it means to BE Native has changed outwardly in our culture, but where it shouldn't (tribally), it is now fraught with economic and cultural bias. Having a Native ancestor isn't the same as 'being Native', and the onslaught of Ancestry DNA results is creating a new schism in the Native community- do you accept these cousins, as not their fault their family stepped away from their culture, or because they walked away are they no longer counted as Native? It's a divide that often is determined by tribal limitations for beloninging (mostly based on colonizer blood quantums, not historical tribal counting), and even that is fraught with drama, as some holders of tribal cards are getting kicked off their tribal roles due to new 'recounting'. So yes the question of are you "Indian Enough?" is a modern minefield of emotions and cultural trauma. 

In this collection of essays mainly about his life, Paul shows how even when you are Native, you might not be deemed 'enough of a Native' to make decisions or have your voice truly heard, but on the flip side, you might be 'Native enough' to be counted for DEI purposes. I had followed the founding and making of NMAI, and through his essays I know understand why so much seemed out of sync with that the original stated purposes and goals were. It wasn't a museum of Native Awareness made by Natives, but with assistance from them. There was failure built into the design. The question is whether it was intentional or accidental...sigh. 

Smith gives those unaware of tribal issues versus modern culture of modern Native Americans a chance to understand the issues from a personal perspective, and I highly recommend it as the one book you should read this month, as part of native American appreciation month. If you want further reading, I recommend The Great Vanishing Act: Blood Quantum and the Future of Native Nations by Kathleen Ratteree and Playing Indian by Phillip Deloria- both deal with concepts brought forth in Indian Enough's essays and give more thorough discussions on them.


About the Author: 

Paul Chaat Smith (Comanche) is author of Indian Enough: Essays and Everything You Know about Indians Is Wrong, published by the University of Minnesota Press, and coauthor with Robert Warrior of Like a Hurricane: The Indian Movement from Alcatraz to Wounded Knee. He was curator at the Smithsonian’s National Museum of the American Indian for twenty-four years.

Comments

Follow and Share:

twitterfacebookbluesky appinstagrampinterestemail